PeterRabit

Peter Robinson

PeterRabit’s Activity

Today

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 2 hours ago

Re: The One-State solution

Alb The magic number is when there's a sufficient electoral base to begin implementing a shift towards an Islamic - rather than Jewish - government.

Well, let us not leave out the possibility of secular government (a well proven [more]

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 4 hours ago

Re: Einstein argued against the creation of Isra

agnes >In the US media, the coverage is much more favorable towards Israel. maybe something to do with jewish lobby in the US?

Hard to say what is cause and what effect. Certainly we can say that the US is exceptional. We have this [more]

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 9:24 AM

Re: The One-State solution

Alb As you point out, Palestinians are not devils who cannot be good citizens - and there are already some 1.6 million non-Jewish citizens of Israel. The issue is not what happens when a very small number of new citizens are added to Israel - the [more]

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 8:15 AM

Re: Einstein argued against the creation of Isra

agnes >Israeli people are brainwashed by their government and media. They live in a bubble.

Brainwashing within Israel does not explain how many Americans and American Jews believe the same stuff. The biggest meme is this:

AS [more]

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 8:08 AM

Re: Einstein argued against the creation of Isra

sano What those 1.6 million Israeli Arabs want is irrelevant to large and well armed terrorist organizations like Hamas and Hezballah.

So if those 1.6 million Israeli Arabs generally vote with the Jews in a Greater Israel, that [more]

Yesterday

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit posted to the Political Asylum board. 9:31 PM

The One-State solution

PR >Do you understand that I am proposing integrating the Pals into a Greater Israel over a 100 year period [if necessary]? One enclave at a time as they show interest.

How would that address the conflict? If you don't allow everyone [more]

Tue Jul 29

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 7:07 PM

Re: I wish to g-d more people could see this

What do you think these millions of people, who have spent their entire lives being told that the Jewish majority population of Israel is the cause of their dire straits, will do if they are in charge of Israel? What group do you think will seize [more]

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 6:24 PM

Re: I wish to g-d more people could see this

Alb They absolutely believe that if you opened the borders of Israel to all the people who aren't currently Israeli citizens, Hamas could win that election.

It is a strange fear. Hamas cannot even win an election in the West [more]

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 6:13 PM

Re: Einstein argued against the creation of Isra

sano In the wake of the holocaust, it made sense that Jews should have a homeland in which they could defend themselves.

Realistically, if that ability to defend themselves for being jewish ends, the prognosis for Jews in the Middle East
[more]

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 5:56 PM

Re: I wish to g-d more people could see this

But they were quite certain about what their fate would be if Hamas (or Hezbollah) were to be elected to govern over a "Greater Israel."

Albaby


There are about 1,658,000 Arab or non-Jewish citizens of Israel. As far [more]

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 1:47 PM

Re: I wish to g-d more people could see this

Sh That'll be tough. Israel was founded in 47' as a Jewish state.

Yep, tough choice.

Cling to this anachronistic non-secular identity and accept the fact that you and your children and your children's children will always [more]

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 1:31 PM

Re: Einstein argued against the creation of Isra

TD1 The West Bank and Gaza are not Israel proper. Why would someone living there get voting rights?

Over 350,000 Jews live in the West Bank. Are you saying that they should NOT have voting rights in Israel?

[more]

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 1:24 PM

Re: I wish to g-d more people could see this

TD1 Bill Clinton offered Arafat everything...and Arafat turned it down. There could have been a two state solution guaranteed by the US. But no sale.

I don't believe a real country (with all normal national rights including contiguous [more]

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit posted to the Political Asylum board. 1:03 PM

I wish to g-d more people could see this

Felix:

Palestinians in the Occupied Territories don't have full voting and civil rights. This is the crux of Israel's dilemma: how to annex the West Bank (a.k.a. Judea and Samaria) or significant chunks of it, without giving the [more]

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 12:46 PM

Re: Einstein argued against the creation of Isra

Hw No, in a court of law, the witness would actually have to prove that they have some level of expertese to testify on the topic.

Simply being a humanitarian and nobel-winning scientist would not be sufficient to provide evidence on
[more]

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 12:43 PM

Re: Einstein argued against the creation of Isra

A Palestinian woman in Israel has more rights living Tel Aviv than in Gaza or the West Bank.

No sh!t, Sherlock.

Do you any problem with granting political rights to a Pal woman living in the West Bank or Gaza? (Assume no [more]

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 11:32 AM

Re: Einstein argued against the creation of Isra

Hw No, we will just question your Appeal to Authority.

"Appeal to Authority" is only a fallacy in PURE LOGIC. In any other context (a court of law for example) it is commonplace.

Do you understand me?

Peter

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 11:30 AM

Re: Einstein argued against the creation of Israel

Judge Hutcheson: I have asked these various persons if it is essential to the right or the privilege of the Jews to go to Palestine, if it is essential to real Zionism that a setup be fixed so that the Jews have a Jewish state and a Jewish [more]

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 11:17 AM

Re: 'The growing Islamic State'

PR >Now everyone should understand that ISIS is a Shia Muslim group.

lFO >No they are Sunni.

You are correct. My mistake.

Hezbollah is Shia.

Peter

NL

Boards Post

PeterRabit replied to the Political Asylum board. 10:26 AM

Re: 'The growing Islamic State'

But to clarify my Islamic State comments. Like virtually every country on earth, including the USA, I am very worried about the Growing Islamic State. They represent a consideration of everything that's bad in the Islamic world today, and they have [more]

Show More Activity ...

CAPS Stats & Trivia

CAPS Player Rating 29.46
Player Rank 52896 out of 74988
Score -249.32
Score Change Today -2.20
Accuracy 44.83%
Active Picks 7
Total Picks 32
Best Pick PPP (+133.06)
Worst Pick GORO (-118.62)
Average Score per Pick -7.79
Charms Earned 3
Highest Rated Favorite No Favorites Selected
Go to PeterRabit’s CAPS page

Boards Stats & Trivia

Big funky green star, 20000 posts Top Recommended Fools Old School Fool
Board Posts 34960
Recs Received 62292
People who have rec'd these posts 1949
Recs to Posts Ratio (last 30 days) 24.90
Threads Started 5942
Threads Started Percentage 17.00 %
Most Frequent Board Political Asylum
Very First Post ETF alternative to Vanguard VBMFX? (5/16/2001)
Percentage of Posts Rec'd 41.50 %
Show PeterRabit’s 10 Latest Posts